Buying guide
Pantry for Pizza Night
Updated How we research
The shelf-stable staples behind pizzeria-level flavor. The page is split into five sections (Start with the flour; Tomatoes worth crushing; Yeast you can trust; Cheese that melts right; Finish with a drizzle), followed by every pick ranked by our score so you can compare them in one place.
The short version
We compared 20 picks. Our scores range from 6.2 to 9.1 out of 10.
- Best overall:Antimo Caputo Pizzeria Flour Blue, 11 Pound (5Kg) Bag - Italian 00 Flour for Neapolitan Pizza Dough. Highest overall score in this guide at 9.1/10.
- Also great value:Polselli Classica, Tipo "00" Double Zero Flour Extra Fine, 11 lbs (5 kg), Neapolitan Italian Pizza Flour. Value score of 9/10, overall 8.8/10.
- Solid build:Polselli Pizza Flour, Type 00, 2.2 lbs - Napoletana, Roman, or Traditional Pizzeria Crust, Double Zero. Build and materials score of 9/10, overall 8.6/10.
- Feature-rich:Cento Anna Napoletana Tipo "00" Extra Fine Unbleached Flour, 11 Pound, Grown and Milled in Italy. Features score of 8/10, overall 8.6/10.
Scores are our editorial assessment, not customer ratings. How we score
Start with the flour
- Antimo Caputo Pizzeria Flour Blue, 11 Pound (5Kg) Bag - Italian 00 Flour for Neapolitan Pizza DoughOur score9.1/10
- Polselli Classica, Tipo "00" Double Zero Flour Extra Fine, 11 lbs (5 kg), Neapolitan Italian Pizza FlourOur score8.8/10
- Polselli Pizza Flour, Type 00, 2.2 lbs - Napoletana, Roman, or Traditional Pizzeria Crust, Double ZeroOur score8.6/10
- Cento Anna Napoletana Tipo "00" Extra Fine Unbleached Flour, 11 Pound, Grown and Milled in ItalyOur score8.6/10
Tomatoes worth crushing
- Flora Foods Tomatoes San Marzano DOP, 28 oz (793g), 100% Italian Quality, Imported (12 Pack)Our score8.6/10
- La Valle San Marzano DOP Tomatoes, 1.75 Pound (Pack of 5)Our score8.1/10
- La Valle San Marzano D.O.P. Italian Peeled Tomatoes, 6-Pack of 28 oz CansOur score8.1/10
- San Marzano DOP Authentic Whole Peeled Plum Tomatoes, 1.75 Pound (Pack of 6)Our score7.8/10
Yeast you can trust
- LeSaffre Saf-Instant Yeast, Red, 2 PoundOur score8.5/10
- Fleischmann's Instant Dry Yeast, 16 Ounce - 1 Pack, Fast-Acting, Gluten Free, No PreservativesOur score8.3/10
- Fleischmann's Pizza Crust Yeast, Specially Formulated For Pizza Crust, 0.75 oz (Pack of 4)Our score7.8/10
- Fleischmann's Yeast Pizza, 0.25-Ounce Pouches, 3 Count (Pack of 5)Our score7.6/10
Cheese that melts right
- Whole Milk Mozzarella Cheese - Low Moisture, 3 lb Loaf, Authentic Wisconsin Mozzarella for Pizza, Pasta & MoreOur score8.4/10
- Sorrento Low Moisture Whole Milk Medium Diced Shredded Mozzarella/Provolone Blend Cheese, 5 Pound - 6 per caseOur score7.6/10
- Galbani Whole Milk Low Moisture Mozzarella Cheese, 5 Pound - 6 per caseOur score7.4/10
- Amazon Grocery, Mozzarella Cheese, Shredded, 8 OzOur score7.2/10
Finish with a drizzle
- Graza Drizzle Extra Virgin Olive Oil, Finishing Oil - High Polyphenol Early Harvest EVOO in a Squeeze Bottle, 16.9 Fl OzOur score8.4/10
- COSTABILE Hot Chili Oil - Extra Virgin Olive Oil from Italy Infused with Spicy Red Peppers, 8.45 Fl OzOur score8.1/10
- Tony Gemignani Olive Oil, Hot PepperOur score6.9/10
- Benissimo Spicy Sriracha Oil, Herb Infused Cooking Oil, 8.12 ozOur score6.2/10
All 20 picks, ranked by our score
Every product from the sections above, listed once. Sort by the criterion you care about most, or tick up to three to compare.
#1Antimo Caputo Pizzeria Flour Blue, an 11 Pound (5Kg) bag of Italian 00 flour for Neapolitan pizza dough.
Fit for the job 10/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 9/10
- + Pizzeria Blue flour is designed for long fermentation and high-heat ovens
- + 11 Pound (5Kg) bag lowers cost per pizza for regular bakers
- + Italian 00 flour from Naples' best-known mill
- - Designed for very hot ovens, so it browns less in home ovens
- - Large bag needs airtight storage to stay fresh
#2Polselli Classica Tipo "00" double zero extra fine flour, an 11 lbs (5 kg) bag of Neapolitan Italian pizza flour.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 9/10
- + Extra fine double zero flour creates airy, tender crusts
- + 11 lbs (5 kg) size is economical for frequent pizza makers
- + Classica line is made for Neapolitan-style pizza
- - Bulk bag takes pantry space and needs sealing
- - Best results need a hot oven rather than a standard kitchen oven
#3Polselli's Type 00 pizza flour, a 2.2 lbs bag for Napoletana, Roman or traditional pizzeria crusts.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 8/10
- + Double Zero flour gives soft, extensible dough
- + Suits Napoletana, Roman and traditional pizzeria styles
- + 2.2 lbs bag is a low-commitment way to try Italian flour
- - Small bag runs out after a few pizza nights
- - Imported flour costs more per pound than domestic bread flour
#4Cento Anna Napoletana Tipo "00" extra fine unbleached flour, an 11 Pound bag grown and milled in Italy.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 8/10
- + Unbleached extra fine flour keeps a natural wheat flavor
- + Grown and milled in Italy for authentic Napoletana dough
- + 11 Pound bag suits regular pizza bakers who go through flour fast
- - Large bag may go stale for occasional bakers
- - Softer 00 flour can tear if you stretch dough too thin
#5Flora Foods San Marzano DOP tomatoes, 28 oz (793g) imported cans in a 12 Pack, marketed as 100% Italian quality.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 9/10
- + 12 Pack of large cans suits families and frequent pizza bakers
- + Imported DOP tomatoes bring the classic sweet, low-acid profile to sauce
- + 28 oz cans make enough sauce for several pizzas per can
- - Twelve large cans take up a good chunk of pantry shelf space
- - Big upfront order if you only make pizza now and then
#6LeSaffre Saf-Instant red yeast in a 2 Pound package, a bakery staple for pizza and bread doughs.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 9/10 · Value 9/10
- + Saf-Instant red is a trusted yeast in professional bakeries
- + 2 Pound package lasts a long time when stored in the freezer
- + Instant yeast works well for both same-day and cold-fermented dough
- - 2 Pound is far more than casual pizza makers will use
- - Must be resealed carefully to keep yeast active
#7A 3 lb loaf of low moisture whole milk mozzarella, authentic Wisconsin cheese for pizza, pasta and more.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + Low moisture mozzarella melts without flooding the pizza with water
- + Whole milk gives a richer flavor and better browning than part skim
- + 3 lb loaf lets you shred fresh for each pizza night
- - Large loaf must be used or frozen before it spoils once opened
- - Whole milk mozzarella can brown quickly, so watch it near the end of baking
#8Graza Drizzle extra virgin olive oil, a high polyphenol early harvest finishing EVOO in a 16.9 Fl Oz squeeze bottle.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + Squeeze bottle makes a thin, even drizzle over Margherita pizzas
- + Early harvest EVOO has a bold, peppery finish for raw drizzling
- + 16.9 Fl Oz bottle suits frequent pizza and salad use
- - No chili infusion, so it adds richness rather than heat
- - Plastic squeeze bottle is less protective than dark glass for storage
#9Fleischmann's instant dry yeast, a 16 Ounce fast-acting pack, gluten free with no preservatives.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 9/10
- + 16 Ounce pack is far cheaper per batch than individual pouches
- + Instant yeast mixes directly into flour with no proofing step
- + Gluten free and preservative free yeast suits many diets
- - Large pack needs airtight fridge or freezer storage after opening
- - Easy to overuse without a precise scale for small amounts
#10La Valle San Marzano DOP tomatoes, 1.75 Pound cans in a Pack of 5 for sauce made the traditional way.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + La Valle is a recognized Italian tomato brand with DOP certification
- + Pack of 5 is a manageable pantry stock for home pizza makers
- + Whole San Marzano tomatoes give bright, simple pizza sauce
- - Fewer cans than some multi-packs for a similar outlay
- - Cans need draining of excess juice to avoid soggy pizzas
#11La Valle San Marzano D.O.P. Italian peeled tomatoes in a 6-Pack of 28 oz cans for sauce and cooking.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + D.O.P. certified tomatoes offer traceable Italian origin
- + 6-Pack of 28 oz cans covers pizza sauce plus pasta nights
- + Peeled tomatoes blend into a smooth or rustic sauce as you prefer
- - Large cans can be too much for a single pizza, so plan leftovers
- - Price per can is higher than non-DOP plum tomatoes
#12COSTABILE hot chili oil, extra virgin olive oil from Italy infused with spicy red peppers, 8.45 Fl Oz.
Fit for the job 9/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + Italian extra virgin olive oil base adds fruity richness to pizza crusts
- + Spicy red pepper infusion gives a pizzeria-style chili drizzle
- + 8.45 Fl Oz bottle is a handy size for the table
- - Infused oils lose punch if left open near a hot oven
- - Taste a small drizzle first since chili heat varies by batch
#13San Marzano DOP authentic whole peeled plum tomatoes, 1.75 Pound cans in a Pack of 6 for classic pizza sauce.
Fit for the job 8/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + DOP labeling means the tomatoes come from the protected San Marzano area
- + Whole peeled plums crush by hand into a fresh, uncooked pizza sauce
- + Pack of 6 keeps sauce on hand for many pizza nights
- - Brand name is not clear in the listing, which makes quality harder to trace
- - Whole tomatoes need crushing and draining before they suit thin pizzas
#14Fleischmann's Pizza Crust Yeast, specially formulated for pizza crust, 0.75 oz packets in a Pack of 4.
Fit for the job 8/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + Formulated so dough relaxes and stretches without long resting times
- + Quick option for same-day pizza without planning a cold ferment
- + Fleischmann's yeast is sold nearly everywhere in the US
- - Fast yeast gives less flavor than a slow, overnight dough
- - Small packets add up in cost for frequent bakers
#15Fleischmann's pizza yeast in 0.25-Ounce pouches, 3 Count strips in a Pack of 5 for regular same-day dough.
Fit for the job 8/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 7/10
- + Pre-measured pouches make weighing tiny yeast amounts unnecessary
- + Pack of 5 strips keeps a steady supply in the pantry
- + Pizza-specific yeast suits quick rise weeknight dough
- - Pouch format costs much more per ounce than bulk yeast
- - Not ideal for long cold fermentation schedules
#16Sorrento low moisture whole milk medium diced mozzarella and provolone blend, 5 Pound bags with 6 per case.
Fit for the job 7/10 · Features and specs 8/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + Mozzarella and provolone blend adds sharper flavor to pizza
- + Medium diced cut melts evenly and spreads quickly
- + 6 per case suits pizzerias and high-volume kitchens
- - Bulk case is impractical for most home kitchens
- - Provolone blend is not ideal for classic Margherita-style pies
#17Galbani whole milk low moisture mozzarella cheese, 5 Pound loaves with 6 per case for foodservice-level pizza making.
Fit for the job 7/10 · Features and specs 7/10 · Build and materials 8/10 · Value 8/10
- + 6 per case of 5 Pound loaves serves pizzerias or large events
- + Whole milk low moisture style gives classic pizzeria melt
- + Galbani quality is consistent across a big supply
- - Case size is far beyond normal home fridge capacity
- - Perishable bulk cheese risks waste without high usage
#18An 8 oz bag of shredded low-moisture part-skim mozzarella from Amazon Grocery. The small, low-cost option in this guide for topping one or two pies without buying a bulk block.
Fit for the job 7/10 · Features and specs 6/10 · Build and materials 7/10 · Value 9/10
- + Listed as low-moisture part-skim mozzarella, the style this guide covers, in a ready-to-use shred
- + 8 oz bag suits a single pizza night, with no leftover multi-pound block to wrap and store
- + Low price per bag, and the listing notes milk from cows not treated with rBST
- - Part-skim rather than whole milk, so it is not the whole-milk style several other picks here offer
- - Pre-shredded only, with no block option on this listing for bakers who prefer to grate or slice their own
#19Tony Gemignani hot pepper olive oil, a chili-infused drizzle from a well-known competitive pizza chef.
Fit for the job 8/10 · Features and specs 5/10 · Build and materials 7/10 · Value 7/10
- + Created by a famous pizza chef with pizza drizzling in mind
- + Hot pepper infusion adds heat to crusts and cheese pizzas
- + Easy way to give home pizza a pizzeria finish
- - Compare cost per ounce since bottle sizes vary between orders
- - Infused oils are not always extra virgin, so check if that matters
#20Benissimo spicy sriracha oil, an 8.12 oz herb infused cooking oil with garlic-chili sriracha flavor.
Fit for the job 6/10 · Features and specs 6/10 · Build and materials 6/10 · Value 7/10
- + Sriracha flavor gives a tangy, garlicky twist on standard chili oil
- + Herb infused oil works for cooking and finishing
- + 8.12 oz bottle is a reasonable size to try something different
- - Sriracha taste strays from traditional Italian pizza flavors
- - Check the label if you specifically want an extra virgin base
Popular right now
- Best Semolina Flour for Pizza Peels and Crispier CrustsBuying guide
- Troubleshooting Soggy Pizza CentersArticle
- Best Low-Moisture Mozzarella for Homemade PizzaBuying guide
- Best Pizza Stone Sets with Peels and AccessoriesBuying guide
- Semolina vs Flour for DustingArticle
- Best Perforated Pizza Peels for Home OvensBuying guide
Based on the last 28 days of search and visitor data.
Pizza Oven Craft curates picks for US shoppers. Scores are our editorial assessment. We may earn a commission from links on this page.